Palestinians gather next to the body of Omar Hamed during his funeral at the village of Beitin, near the West Bank city of Ramallah in the occupied West Bank, Sunday, April 14, 2024. Israeli settlers in the occupied West Bank went on the largest rampage against Palestinians there since the war in Gaza began, as Israel’s army said Saturday the body of a missing Israeli teen was found after he was killed in a “terrorist attack.” Witnesses said settlers assaulted a number of communities. (AP Photo/Majdi Mohammed)
How many times in your life have you seen someone you care for acting badly? Maybe they are stressed out from a loss of their job and they start drinking. Or maybe they have a relationship issue with their significant other, or someone in their family is being confronted with a devastating life-changing circumstance or a terminal diagnosis? Perhaps a family member was attacked and brutalized? It is possible in cases like this that your friend (anyone) cannot cope in an adaptive way following such tragedy. In that case, it is also possible that they will behave badly, or bridges will be burned and their lives shipwrecked. What do you say to them? Do you speak out in love, or quietly hold your peace (and your breath)? Do you let them break all the dinnerware in an systemative but also indiscriminant rage or do you intervene to restrain them, to call for a timeout? Israel is such a friend to America, and there is a growing consensus here1 and abroad that our friend is behaving badly, not just in Gaza but now increasingly also in the West Bank. I consider myself as a Christian to be a friend of Israel, and I have chosen to no longer remain silent.
I was working with some Old Testament Scripture today and came across a verse in Genesis, chapter 28. The patriarch Jacob, grandson of Abraham, was traveling from Beersheba to Harran as described in Genesis 28:10. Those locations are probably unfamiliar to most people today. They are actually 457 miles apart as the crow flies. In any event, as the sun set one day during his journey and twilight approached, Jacob grew weary and retired for the night (28:11). Soundly asleep, he had a dream of a stairway to heaven (28:12). In his dream, God made promises to Jacob. Finally, when Jacob awoke from his sleep, he thought, “Surely the LORD is in this place, and I was not aware of it” (28:16). In Jacob’s mind, there was no reason or suggestion that the ground he lay on and the rock he used for a pillow were hallowed ground. But I’m sure we can agree that it was likely holy not by virtue of sacred geology as discussed elsewhere on this website, but by the approaching presence of the Lord of Hosts. God met man on that night some 4,000 years ago. And incidentally, God still pops up from time to time when people today least expect it or when they need Him the most.
AI illusrtration by wow (Adobe). Commentators are divided about whether a ladder or staircase is indicated, as the Hebrew word “sullam” is only used here. Most contemporary authorities favor an intertretation that means a ramp or staircase, however, based on the use of the word in other instances at the time.
I wondered exactly what place the Lord was at. And is the LORD’s presence still there? We learn three verses later that Jacob called that place Bethel. It was near Bethel that Abraham and Lot grazed their sheep. And for a short time, the Ark of the Covenant was kept there. But what of God’s presence today in the place formerly known as Bethel? The Talmud implies2 that God’s continued presence is contingent on justice and righteousness being sought and practiced in the land.
The place where Jacob slept that night was in biblical Israel, granted by God to the Jews, specifically through Jacob and his descendants (Genesis 28:13). The land was promised to Jacob’s descendants (28:13), but Jeremiah 7:5-7 attaches a condition.”
“If you really change your ways and your actions and deal with each other justly, if you do not oppress the foreigner, the fatherless or the widow and do not shed innocent blood in this place, and if you do not follow other gods to your own harm, then I will let you live in this place, in the land I gave your ancestors for ever and ever.”
Today, Bethel, like many Biblical cities, has a new name and is under new management. Today it is called Beitin. It is three miles from Ramallah on the West Bank. Between 2,500 and 3,000 Palestinians live in Beitin today and they have (more or less) a form of self-rule under the Oslo agreement and with Israeli concurrence. They might otherwise live in peace under these restrictions. But they are suffering at the hands of the Israeli settlers who commit unprovoked violence against them, in fact, terrorist acts (if U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee can be believed). There or elsewhere in the countryside west of the Jordan River, Palestinians are being beaten and killed by armed mobs of Jewish settlers. Levantine olive trees (some centuries old) are being cut down and burned, baby lambs beaten to death within sight of their ewes and the list of atrocities gets ever longer.
Occasionally a Palestinian is killed by these terrorist gangs. Occasionally a Palestinian family fights back and then the Israel Defense Forces are called in, and other possibly innocent Palestinians die. But clearly, not every Palestinian is innocent. Palestinians are not pacifists like the Quakers. They can and have been given to violence against Jews as brutal as what they have received from Jews3. What I hope to do here is consider the current settler violence in the context of the words God has given to the Jews. I am not a rabbi. I have no formal training in seminary. But if I am not qualified to provide reasonable answers, perhaps then I can at least raise credible questions.
The Jewish vigilantes see this violence against the Arabs as just, believing that the Palestinians are somehow defiling the land God has given Israel by their very presence, let alone through their mosques constructed to worship a strange god. In a sense the Palestinians are being evicted. And if they do not go peacefully, then bloody constraint follows. Yet Scripture is clear. Numbers 35: 33-34 reads (NIV):
Do not pollute the land where you are. Bloodshed pollutes the land, and atonement cannot be made for the land on which blood has been shed, except by the blood of the one who shed it. Do not defile the land where you live and where I dwell, for I, the LORD, dwell among the Israelites.
Settlers who engage in violence are often of the Hardal community. They can be found wearing oversized knitted kippahs, and the adolescents and young men wear sidelocks (peyot), which are occasionally displayed behind their ears. Compared to the Haredim, also common in Israel, who dress in heavy black coats and fedoras, the Hardal take a minimalist, more functional approach to dress. They believe that Israel is a Jewish nation, and this partly explains their intolerance to Muslims (and to Christians as well, by the way). The Hardal have also attacked members of the Israel Defense Forces when these soldiers have been used to dismantle unauthorized or illegal Jewish settlements, and members of the international press present who happen to cover it.
Elisha Yered, an Israeli settler and leading figure with the Hilltop Youth, poses for a portrait in a makeshift clubhouse on a hilltop near the settlement of Maskiot in the northern West Bank, Sunday, May 12, 2024. Yered was sanctioned by the EU and Britain but said nothing will stop his plans to expand. (AP Photo/Maya Alleruzzo)
The Hilltop Youth, perhaps the best-known group of vigilantes in Israel, conduct “price tag” attacks, meaning that anyone who acts contrary to their fundamental beliefs in terms of who is welcome to live in Israel must pay a price.
There is also violence elsewhere in cities such as Jerusalem, where tourists or members of the press, perhaps including clergy, have been spat upon or roughed up or have had garbage hurled at them or their churches. Where is the justice here?
If we read the passage above from Jeremiah Chapter 7 once more, we’ll see that while the Jews have title to the land, their ability to live on it in peace depends on them living justly with their neighbors and particularly if they do not “shed innocent blood.” This is not a burden that God placed uniquely on Israel. He expects all nations to practice justice (including America). Christianity as it is popularly practiced in the U.S. today focuses attention on some demands noted in the Bible to the exclusion of other commandments. Social justice is one such glaring example of nonfeasance. We are reminded of our responsibilities to our Sovereign (Romans 13:1-7) and we focus on pro-life issues as they apply to abortion, but then we turn a blind eye to the responsibilities that the prophets and Jesus, Himself taught.
This brutality might be common in Syria, Yemen or Iran, but then Israel is not Syria, Yemen or Iran. Hamas or West Bank Arab terrorist groups may have little reservation about using their own people as human shields or exploiting whatever benefit of the doubt Israel allows for people in a house in Gaza (for those houses still standing). On the other hand, when is enough, enough? Palestinian terrorists are known to assassinate other Palestinians who they believe are looking for a better future for their families and grandchildren. Then, too, you have the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin by a Jew because Rabin hoped for the same nonviolent future where Jews and Muslims can live together in peace.
It is very difficult to reach an accommodation. You cannot pour money on the people who live in Israel and the Palestinian territories and expect them to support a Macau or Monaco solution to their problems. And Jewish extremists are as opposed to democracy if it includes voting rights to Arab citizens of Israel as Muslim extremists are as far as their own territory is concerned.
In a democracy, even peaceful progress is fraught with risk. If you want an illustration, the October 27 Israeli elections serve well. The Yahar bloc led by Israeli Gadi Eisenkot won 48 seats in parliament. Netanyahu’s Likud did better by winning 53 seats. But they both fell short of the sixty-one seats in the Knesset necessary to govern. The bloc that holds the winning hand is the Arab bloc with 19 seats won. They get to decide who to support and in theory the person they support is the next prime minister of Israel. So, in some sense the Arab-Israeli citizens will decide which prime minister comes to power to govern Israel. While secular, liberal Jews in Israel may be open to that idea and appreciate the irony, this is heresy to religious and ultra-religious Jewish groups alike. And the Arab world is not pinning any hopes on this either.
Was Jacob mistaken when he was convinced that the LORD was in the place that would become known as Bethel and later Beitin? Or, if his conclusion was correct, then where is the LORD now? Is He like the wind, a characteristic of the Holy Spirit, that blows here one moment and is found hundreds or thousands of miles elsewhere the next? And if He is still in Beitin, then how dare any Palestinian yet alone Israeli act so disrespectfully in His presence?! Do we have a responsibility to somehow “demilitarize” Beitin or at least preserve it as a first step towards peace, or a sacred space, even as Catholics preserve Lourdes? Or are the conditions just not right for God to dwell among His people?
1A recent Gallup earlier this year noted that more Americans now sympathize with the Palestinians (41%) than with the Israelis (36%). Meanwhile, Israel’s favorability is near a historic low among Americans.
2Scripture warns us not to defile or allow the land to be defiled as it drives out its people (Leviticus 18:28) and suggests that defilement places the continued presence of God in danger (Numbers 35:34). The Talmud (Shabbat 33a) concludes that for the crime of bloodshed for example, the presence of God is placed in peril.
3We need only be reminded of the October 7th massacre three years ago near Gaza where 1,200 Jews including their households were tortured and killed while another 250 were taken as hostage, with some captive Israelis or citizens of other countries among these being subsequently murdered.
We use cookies to improve your experience on our site. By using our site, you consent to cookies.
Manage your cookie preferences below:
Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.
These cookies are needed for adding comments on this website.
Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us understand how visitors use our website.
Google Analytics is a powerful tool that tracks and analyzes website traffic for informed marketing decisions.
Service URL: policies.google.com (opens in a new window)
You can find more information in our Cookie Policy.